Attorney general wins round in poultry suit

June 2006

U.S. Water News Online

TULSA, Okla. -- A federal magistrate has given Oklahoma permission to take samples of soil, water, waste and runoff from chicken farms as part of its water pollution lawsuit against Arkansas poultry companies.

The ruling by U.S. Magistrate Sam Joyner was in response to motions filed by the companies to prevent the sampling.

"We will be in the field as soon as we can," Attorney General Drew Edmondson said. "The corporate polluters have successfully delayed the sampling for a few months but they cannot delay forever."

Last month, Edmondson issued about two dozen subpoenas requiring landowners to allow investigators to collect the samples. Many of the landowners raise chickens for companies Edmondson has sued.

Edmondson has sued 14 poultry companies, alleging that chicken litter applied as fertilizer by Oklahoma farmers working for Arkansas companies is polluting watersheds.

As part of his ruling, Joyner established procedures for how the sampling would be conducted. The state can enter each farm to take soil, poultry litter and groundwater samples, but must give the farmers 72 hours' notice. The court also limited the state to taking no more than 240 samples per property.

Scott McDaniel, an attorney representing Peterson Farms Inc., one of the 14 poulty companies sued by the state, said the ruling set some of the conditions poultry companies felt were needed.

"All in all, we're pleased," McDaniel said. "The judge reined in some of the overly broad aspects of the subpoenas.

"We're satisfied with what the judge did."

The attorney general's office will be required to set a schedule for sampling properties. Samplers must gather enough material to share it with poultry companies for their analysis.

Poultry company representatives will shadow the sampling to ensure that representatives from the state don't overstep the limits set by the court, McDaniel said.

"The ball is in the attorney general's court," McDaniel said. "We'll be waiting for the schedule."

After almost four years of negotiations, Oklahoma last June filed a federal lawsuit against Tyson Foods Inc., the largest poultry company, and 13 other companies alleging that their operations polluted the Illinois River watershed and Lake Tenkiller.

The suit alleges that the Arkansas-based poultry companies are legally responsible for the pollution that is caused by runoff from improper land application and storage of tons of poultry waste.


Return to the U.S. Water News' Archives page
Or
Return to the U.S. Water News Homepage

Editor@uswaternews.com

 

Forward this article to a friend:

*Your Name:  

*Your Email:  

*Friend's Email:  

Use a comma to separate e-mail addresses:

*Your Comments:

 

 

*Required Fields